Determination of element weight for the purpose of prioritization of intersection collision correction
https://doi.org/10.22227/1997-0935.2024.3.469-477
Abstract
Introduction. It is proposed to optimize the time of highly qualified engineers working with a building information model (BIM) during the correction of intersection collisions due to mathematical determination of importance of an element in intersection collisions.
Materials and methods. The method of frequency analysis is taken as a basis, using the quality coefficient of BIM. The quality coefficient of BIM is determined based on the data about the BIM itself: number of elements, objects and collisions. The calculated coefficients influence the results obtained using the frequency analysis method. As a result, unique values of importance weights for BIM elements are obtained.
Results. The weights of the elements found during the study are sorted in descending order, the first 20 % of the elements with the highest weight are the load-bearing structures, indicating that fixing collisions involving them should be a priority. The priority of correcting collisions involving other non-bearing elements of the BIM can be determined by assigning weights to them based on the elements involved in collisions.
Conclusions. The results of the study will help to assign priority to the intersection collisions found. This, in turn, will allow highly qualified engineers to fix the most important intersection collisions in a priority order, thereby using their time more efficiently. The resulting element weights can be applied by exporting the collisions found in the project to a tabular data format. Using tabular editors and pivot table functions, you can assign weights to elements and sort collisions.
About the Authors
S. I. EvtushenkoRussian Federation
Sergey I. Evtushenko — Doctor of Technical Sciences, Professor of the Department of Information Systems, Technology and Automation of Construction
26 Yaroslavskoe shosse, Moscow, 129337
ID RSCI: 510652, Scopus: 57190962075, ResearcherID: C-5249-2013
R. V. Ostashev
Russian Federation
Roman V. Ostashev — postgraduate student of the Department of Information Systems, Technology and Automation of Construction
26 Yaroslavskoe shosse, Moscow, 129337
References
1. Zakharova Yu., Shishkina M. Automatic collision checks in Pilot-BIM. CAD and Graphics. 2021; 6(296):30-36. EDN NQPPDK. (rus.).
2. How BIM helps to identify collisions: user experience of the Renga system. CAD and Graphics. 2022; 6(308):14-17. EDN TCXRKB. (rus.).
3. Subbotina M. Russian BIM technologies: CADLib Model and Archive as a BIM manager tool. CAD and Graphics. 2022; 1(303):41-45. EDN WTFNYE. (rus.).
4. Alieva D.N. Development of an algorithm for finding collisions when building a BIM model. Construction is the formation of a living environment. XXI International Scientific Conference : collection of materials from the seminar “Youth Innovations”. 2018; 8-10. EDN USLUBL. (rus.).
5. Alieva D.N. Automating the search for collisions when building a BIM model. Days of Student Science : collection of reports of a scientific and technical conference. 2018; 323-325. EDN XSYKUP. (rus.).
6. Remmelg Ya.A., Shiyanov M.A., Kuchere-nko A.S. Automated checks for collisions in the Pilot-BIM program. Education. Science. Production : collection of reports of the XIV International Youth Forum. 2022; 223-227. EDN JEUFWA. (rus.).
7. Lopukhina V.P., Mikhaleva E.A. The concept of BIM technology in design, or technologies in BIM design. XVI Annual scientific session of graduate students and young scientists : materials of the All-Russian Scientific Conference. 2023; 189-191. EDN IZJDCK. (rus.).
8. Yudaeva D.E. BIM technologies and expertise of project documentation. Materials of the All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conference of graduate students, doctoral students and young scientists. 2020; 69-73. EDN IRWTCU. (rus.).
9. Ostashev R. Automated verification of infor-mation models for capital construction projects to miti-gate environmental impact. E3S Web of Conferences. 2023; 383:04073. DOI: 10.1051/e3sconf/202338304073
10. Strug B., Ślusarczyk G. Reasoning about accessibility for disabled using building graph models based on BIM/IFC. Visualization in Engineering. 2017; 5(1):1-12. DOI: 10.1186/s40327-017-0048-z. EDN ZJVJNP.
11. Lu Y., Zhang C. Dynamic data monitoring of building information of nano-modified building steel structure materials using BIM model. Integrated Ferroelectrics. 2021; 216(1):197-213. DOI: 10.1080/10584587.2021.1911269. EDN LMDDTI.
12. Alamedy Sh.G.H. Execution quality of construction projects with building information modeling BIM-technology. Ingineering Journal of Don. 2023; 4(100):661-683. EDN LQAWPY.
13. Emelyanov E.G. Modern technologies of information modeling — building information modeling (BIM). Engineering and Social systems : collection of scientific papers of the Institute of Civil Engineering of the IVSPU. 2018; 181-183. EDN XVODFZ. (rus.).
14. Chervova N.A., Lepeshkina D.O. Collisions of general utilities designing through the use of BIM-platforms. Construction of Unique Buildings and Structures. 2018; 3(66):19-29. DOI: 10.18720/CUBS.66.2. EDN XTYVNZ. (rus.).
15. Chervova N.A., Lepeshkina D.O. Tools for finding collisions of engineering systems when working in BIM platforms. Scientific community of students of the XXI century. Technical Sciences : electronic collection of articles based on the materials of the LXIV student International Scientific and Practical Conference. 2018; 22-29. EDN XONKXJ. (rus.).
16. Kochkareva M.B. Advantages of BIM tech-nologies in solving problem issues of renovation and reconstruction of external utilities. Innovative methods of organizing construction production : materials of the II All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conference. 2023; 126-131. EDN ZRIJDW. (rus.).
17. Ivanov A.Yu., Livanov V.A. BIM-models: the fight against collisions in the design of engineering systems. AVOK. 2023; 5:52-64. EDN YJRKUS. (rus.).
18. Kuras M.V., Islamgalieva D.R., Nurisla-mova R.K. Management of building engineering net-works using a BIM model. Actual problems of technical, natural and humanitarian sciences : proceedings of the International Scientific and Technical Conference. 2021; 17-21. EDN NPZCBO. (rus.).
19. Evtushenko S., Ostashev R. Sorting of intersection collisions. Construction and Architecture. 2023; 11(3):10. DOI: 10.29039/2308-0191-2023-11-3-10-10. EDN KFKUHU. (rus.).
20. Ashmarin I.P., Vorobyev A.A. Statistical met-hods in microbiological research. Leningrad, Medgiz Publ., 1962; 180. (rus.).
Review
For citations:
Evtushenko S.I., Ostashev R.V. Determination of element weight for the purpose of prioritization of intersection collision correction. Vestnik MGSU. 2024;19(3):469-477. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.22227/1997-0935.2024.3.469-477